The U.S. Supreme Court has ruled that a key provision of the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) is unconstitutional, clearing the...Read more
Pa. High Court Rules Joint Account Is Safe From Creditor
- May 13th, 2004
Recently we reported on a Pennsylvania couple who may have lost their life savings by making a fundamental estate planning mistake. (See "Couple Makes Basic Planning Error and Loses Life Savings," April 27, 2004).
The couple put their daughter's name on their bank accounts. The bank later claimed the money in the accounts to pay off the debts of the daughter's soon-to-be ex-husband.
But a very similar case just decided by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court suggests that the couple may have a strong case against the bank. Here are the facts of the recent case:
In 1994, Ruth Libros opened a brokerage account with Morgan Stanley Dean Witter. The account was a joint account between Mrs. Libros, her son and her daughter. The account was created as an estate planning device and to allow Mrs. Libros's children to make withdrawals if she became incapacitated. Mrs. Libros made all contributions to the account. Later, the daughter was convicted of embezzling funds from the law firm where she was employed as a bookkeeper. After obtaining a civil judgment against the daughter for $300,000, the law firm sought to collect from the mother's Morgan Stanley account.
Two lower courts concluded that thanks to a Pennsylvania law called the Multiple-Party Accounts Act (MPAA), the joint account belonged entirely to Mrs. Libros because she was the sole contributor. The MPAA provides that when a joint account is created with a financial institution, the account belongs to the parties in proportion to the contributions made by each to the account. Since the daughter had contributed nothing to the account, none of the money was hers and the law firm couldn't get at it. The law firm appealed, arguing that a brokerage account does not fall within the MPAA's definition of "account" and that Morgan Stanley is not a "financial institution" as defined in the statute.
The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania agreed with the lower courts and ruled against the law firm. The court held that the MPAA covers brokerage accounts at investment houses like Morgan Stanley. Therefore, Mrs. Libros's daughter had no ownership interest when the law firm sought to satisfy its $300,000 judgment. At most, all she has is the expectation that the money would be hers (and her brother's) upon her mother's death.
Many other states have statutes similar to Pennsylvania's MPAA. But don't rely on them to protect you from the dangers of joint accounts. Joint accounts, sometimes called "the poor man's will," are generally a bad idea for several reasons. Instead, consult with an elder law attorney about meeting your overall estate planning goals without jeopardizing your savings.
To download the full text of the court's decision in Deutsch v. Johnson (Pa. No. J-126-2003, April 29, 2004), in PDF format, go to: http://www.courts.state.pa.us/OpPosting/Supreme/out/J-126-2003oaj.pdf. (If you do not have the free PDF reader installed on your computer, download it here.)
Local Elder Law Attorneys in Ashburn, VA
Margaret A. O'Reilly, PC
Margaret A. O’Reilly is an estate planning and elder law attorney with over thirty-five years of legal experience. Attorney O’Reilly graduated from Duke University with a degree in psychology, and received her law degree from Northeastern University School of Law in Boston, Massachusetts. For over 15 y...
Hale Ball Carlson Baumgartner Murphy PLC
Attorney Samantha Simmons Fredieu is an associate at Hale Ball. Ms. Fredieu graduated magna cum laude from Vermont Law School where she was the symposium editor on the Vermont Law Review, a production editor on the Vermont Journal of Environmental Law, and a member of the Moot Court Advisory Board. She has clerked for...
Needham Mitnick & Pollack, PLC
Judith Mtinick is well known for acting as a guardian, conservator, trustee or agent on behalf of clients or by court appointment. This experience gives her a wide perspective and extensive practical knowledge that she uses when advising clients in drafting their planning documents. Her experience, as a court appointed...