Grandparents may be tempted to leave an IRA to a grandchild because children have a low tax rate, but the "kiddie tax&qu...Read more
Judge Orders Refund to Estate That Paid Tax Before Madoff Con Was Revealed
- June 14th, 2013
When New Jersey resident Theodore Warshaw died in 2006, his estate was valued at more than $1.8 million. Because any amounts in an estate above $675,000 are subject to estate tax in New Jersey, Mr. Warshaw’s executors paid $88,677 to the state.
The bulk of Mr. Warshaw’s assets were held in an IRA, and when he died the IRA went to a trust to benefit his widow. The IRA assets were allegedly being invested in stocks, bonds and other financial instruments by Bernard L. Madoff Securities, LLC. Mr. Madoff’s company reported that at the time of Mr. Warshaw’s death the value of the IRA was more than $1.4 million.
Local Elder Law Attorneys in Ashburn, VA
Ron M. Landsman, P.A.
Ron M. Landsman has been practicing elder law since 1983, before it was known as elder law, originally with Landsman and Laster, Washington, D.C., then Landsman, Eakes and Laster, also in Arlington, VA, and since 1990 in his own practice in Montgomery County, Maryland. He has been among the most active members of the...
Needham Mitnick & Pollack, PLC
Susan Pollack served as Chairperson of the Falls Church Senior Citizens Commission from 1997 to 2011 and was on the Executive Board of the Falls Church Education Foundation. She has also served on the Board of Directors of the Alzheimer’s Association of the National Capital Area and is a member of the Arlington B...
Needham Mitnick & Pollack, PLC
Judith Mtinick is well known for acting as a guardian, conservator, trustee or agent on behalf of clients or by court appointment. This experience gives her a wide perspective and extensive practical knowledge that she uses when advising clients in drafting their planning documents. Her experience, as a court appointed...
In December 2008, Mr. Madoff was arrested and it was revealed that Mr. Warshaw was among the victims of the largest Ponzi scheme in U.S. history. The money in Mr. Warshaw’s IRA was not being invested but instead had been used to pay other “investors.” The IRA’s value was not $1.4 million but $0.
Learning this, Mr. Warshaw’s estate requested a refund of the $88,677 estate tax it had paid New Jersey. The estate argued that the IRA actually had no value at the time of Mr. Warshaw’s death and that therefore his taxable estate was well below the state’s $675,000 threshold. New Jersey’s Division of Taxation denied the requested refund.
Both sides asked the Tax Court of New Jersey to rule in their favor without a trial. In its argument to the court, the state Division of Taxation cited a 1929 U.S. Supreme Court holding that the value of assets in a taxable estate cannot be determined by events after the date of a death. Ithaca Trust Co. v. United States, 279 U.S. 151.
On June 28, 2012, the Tax Court of New Jersey ruled that the Division owes Mr. Washaw’s estate the refund. The court wrote that despite the 1929 Supreme Court ruling, “subsequent events may be considered to establish evidence of fair market value as it existed on the date of death.” The court held that the discovery of Madoff's Ponzi scheme was relevant to the determination of the IRA’s value at the time of Mr. Warshaw’s death, and that the IRA was in fact worthless at that time.
Last Modified: 06/14/2013