Search Articles

Find Attorneys

Congress Passes Bill Containing Punitive New Medicaid Transfer Rules

  • February 1st, 2006

By a vote of 216-214, the U.S. House of Representatives has passed budget legislation that will impose punitive new restrictions on the ability of the elderly to transfer assets before qualifying for Medicaid coverage of nursing home care. The Deficit Reduction Act of 2005 now goes to President Bush for his promised signature.

Several Republican moderates who had supported the bill when it was voted on in December changed their votes after learning details of the legislation and under intense pressure from groups like AARP, but in the end the vote switches were not enough to defeat a bill that the Congressional Budget Office says will reduce or bar benefits for millions of Medicaid recipients. The measure is estimated to save $39 billion over five years.

Rep. Frank LoBiondo (R-NJ) cast the deciding vote, breaking a 214-214 tie. All House Democrats and 13 Republicans voted against the bill. Republicans who voted yes in December but no in the final vote included Reps. Jim Gerlach (PA), Jim Ramstad (MN), Rob Simmons (CT) and John Sweeney (NY). (Click here to see the full vote.)

Democrats attacked the measure as an assault on Medicaid patients and other vulnerable groups, and said it was a prime example of the powerful influence of lobbyists for corporate interests like drug manufacturers and health insurers, who got much of what they wanted in closed-door negotiations with Republican lawmakers.

"This is a product of special interest lobbying and the stench of special interests hangs over the chamber," said Rep. John Dingell (D-MI).

The Impact on the Elderly

The legislation will extend Medicaid's "lookback" period for all asset transfers from three to five years and change the start of the penalty period for transferred assets from the date of transfer to the date when the individual transferring the assets enters a nursing home and would otherwise be eligible for Medicaid coverage. In other words, the penalty period does not begin until the nursing home resident is out of funds, meaning she cannot afford to pay the nursing home.

Because the change in the penalty period start date will likely leave nursing homes on the hook for the care of residents waiting out extended penalty periods, ElderLawAnswers has dubbed the bill 'The Nursing Home Bankruptcy Act of 2005.' Nursing homes will likely be flooded with residents who need care but have no way to pay for it. In states that have so-called "filial responsibility laws," the nursing homes may seek reimbursement from the residents' children.

The bill also will make any individual with home equity above $500,000 ineligible for Medicaid nursing home care, although states may raise this threshold as high as $750,000.

The legislation also:

  • Establishes new rules for the treatment of annuities, including a requirement that the state be named as the remainder beneficiary.
  • Allows Continuing Care Retirement Communities (CCRCs) to require residents to spend down their declared resources before applying for medical assistance.
  • Sets forth rules under which an individual's CCRC entrance fee is considered an available resource.
  • Requires all states to apply the so-called 'income-first' rule to community spouses who appeal for an increased resource allowance based on their need for more funds invested to meet their minimum income requirements.
  • Extends long-term care partnership programs to any state.
  • Authorizes states to include home and community-based services as an optional Medicaid benefit. (Previously, states had to obtain a waiver to provide such services.)
In addition, the legislation incorporates provisions in the original budget bill passed by the Senate closing certain asset transfer "loopholes," among them:

  • The purchase of a life estate will be included in the definition of "assets" unless the purchaser resides in the home for at least one year after the date of purchase.
  • Funds to purchase a promissory note, loan or mortgage will be included among assets unless the repayment terms are actuarially sound, provide for equal payments and prohibit the cancellation of the balance upon the death of the lender.
  • States will be barred from "rounding down" fractional periods of ineligibility when determining ineligibility periods resulting from asset transfers.
  • States will be permitted to treat multiple transfers of assets as a single transfer and begin any penalty period on the earliest date that would apply to such transfers.

While the federal law applies to all transfers made on or after the date of enactment (which looks like it will be February 8, when President Bush is scheduled to sign the law), it also gives the states time to come into compliance. This gives many people in most states a little time to plan. The deadline for states to enact their own laws varies from state to state, but generally is the first day of the first calendar quarter beginning after the end of the next full legislative session.

The bottom line is if you have been hesitating about seeing an attorney about long-term care planning, hesitate no longer. If you have considered protecting some assets for your loved ones in case you later require long-term care, you should contact a qualified elder law attorney now.

For the full text of the Deficit Reduction Act of 2005 in PDF format, click on: http://www.rules.house.gov/109/text/s1932cr/109s1932_text.pdf The section on the transfer provisions begins on page 222.

For the full text in HTML, go to http://thomas.loc.gov/ and type "S 1932" in the Search Bill Text box. Then click on the fourth version of the bill (S. 1932 EAS).

For an Associated Press article on the vote, click here.

Local Elder Law Attorneys in Your City

Elder Law Attorney

Firm Name
City, State

Elder Law Attorney

Firm Name
City, State

Elder Law Attorney

Firm Name
City, State


Last Modified: 02/01/2006

Medicaid Rules, etc

View All Elder Law Topics Questions & Answers State Medicaid Information